Skip to content
PPMyTrustCredit
Back to blog
#investing#personal-loan#budgeting#guide

Should you borrow to invest? Shares, crypto, gold and ASB: the maths and the risks

A flat-rate personal loan costs far more than its headline rate. The hurdle your investment has to clear, the comparison most people skip, and why a lender is telling you this.

Daniel Lim9 min read
MyTrustCredit · Blog

The pitch, and the question underneath it

The argument is simple and it sounds like arithmetic. A loan costs 8% a year. ASB paid 5.75 sen a unit for 2025, EPF declared 6.15%, a friend's shares are up 30% and a coin doubled last month. Borrow now, invest the lot, let the returns pay the instalments and keep the difference.

Some people have done exactly this and come out ahead. They are also the only ones who talk about it. Before you join them there are two questions to answer with a calculator rather than with a feeling: what does the loan really cost, and what happens to you in the years when the investment does not behave.

This is general information, not investment advice. We are a lender, so we will also say plainly where we stand at the end.

The hurdle: what a flat-rate loan really costs

Moneylender personal loans are generally quoted at a flat rate, and bank personal financing commonly has been too, although banks must move off flat-rate pricing from 1 January 2027 (see /blog/flat-rate-rule-of-78-ban-2027-malaysia). Flat interest is charged on the full amount borrowed for the whole term, even though you hand part of the principal back every month. The true cost of the money you actually have in hand is therefore much higher than the quoted figure.

Take RM 20,000 over five years at 8% a year flat. That rate is an illustration, not a quote. Interest is RM 20,000 x 8% x 5 = RM 8,000. You repay RM 28,000 in 60 instalments of RM 466.67. Because your outstanding balance falls every month while the interest does not, the effective rate on a reducing-balance basis works out to about 14.1% a year. Add stamp duty and any processing fee and it is higher again.

So the question is not whether your investment can beat 8%. To repay RM 28,000 from a RM 20,000 lump sum, the investment would need to compound at about 7% every single year for five years just to hand you back what you paid, with nothing left over for the risk you took. To beat the loan in the proper sense, it has to earn more than about 14% a year, reliably, after fees and tax.

The comparison most people skip

Borrowing to invest is usually compared with doing nothing. The fair comparison is with the alternative you already have: not borrowing, and putting the same RM 466.67 a month into the same investment yourself.

Use a steady 5.75% a year for both paths, purely to keep the sum simple; no fund promises that. On the borrowed path, RM 20,000 invested on day one grows to about RM 26,450 after five years. You have paid RM 28,000 in instalments to get it. On the saving path, RM 466.67 a month for 60 months grows to about RM 32,230. Same monthly cash from the same salary, and the saver finishes roughly RM 5,800 ahead.

The result does not depend on the 8%. At a 4% flat rate the instalment is RM 400 and the total repaid is RM 24,000, which looks like a win against RM 26,450. But RM 400 a month saved for 60 months at the same 5.75% reaches about RM 27,630. The saver is still ahead, because 4% flat is about 7.4% effective, and that is still more than 5.75%.

That is the whole rule. Leverage only pays when the return is higher than the effective borrowing rate. When it is lower, the loan is simply a way of paying a lender for the privilege of investing sooner.

Asset by asset: what the loan is being asked to beat

  • ASB: capital has been stable at RM 1 a unit and the 2025 distribution was 5.75 sen. That is below the effective cost of almost any personal loan, so the sum above applies directly. Bank ASB financing is a separate product with its own pricing, tenure and early-termination terms, and has to be judged on those; it is not the same as putting a personal loan into ASB. Past distributions are not a promise of future ones.
  • Shares: long-run returns can exceed borrowing costs, but they do not arrive evenly. If the market is down 30% in year one, your RM 20,000 is worth RM 14,000 while the instalment is unchanged, and many people sell at that point because they need the cash. A loan turns a temporary paper loss into a permanent one.
  • Gold: it pays no dividend or interest, so every instalment comes out of your salary with nothing coming back until you sell. Physical gold and gold accounts also have a gap between the buying and selling price. And gold can fall for years: it lost more than 40% between its 2011 peak and its 2015 low.
  • Crypto: Bitcoin fell by more than 70% from its 2021 peak to its 2022 low, and smaller tokens routinely go to zero. If you buy at all, use only a digital asset exchange registered with the Securities Commission Malaysia, and understand that no compensation scheme covers a fall in price. A fixed monthly debt is a poor match for an asset that can halve in a month.

What goes wrong in practice

The spreadsheet assumes an average year, every year. Real outcomes depend on the order in which good and bad years arrive, and a borrower is exposed to the worst possible order: a fall early on, when the full amount is invested and the full debt is outstanding.

The instalment is also the only fixed number in the plan. Your returns vary, your income can be interrupted, and the RM 466.67 is due regardless. People who planned for the investment to service the loan discover that distributions are paid yearly while instalments are due monthly.

There is a quieter cost too. The loan sits in your commitments. When you later apply for a home or car loan, the lender counts that instalment against your income and does not count the investment as income. /blog/dsr-calculation-malaysia shows how one extra instalment moves your debt service ratio, and it can be the difference between approval and a smaller offer for the thing you actually wanted.

'Guaranteed returns' plus 'just take a loan' is a scam signature

Be especially careful when the suggestion to borrow comes from the person selling the investment. Schemes that promise fixed monthly returns well above bank rates, and then tell you to fund your place with a personal loan or a credit card, are following a recognisable script. The early 'returns' are paid from later investors' money, and when the scheme stops, the loan is still in your name.

Check before you transfer anything. The Securities Commission publishes an Investor Alert List and a list of licensed and registered intermediaries at sc.com.my, and Bank Negara Malaysia publishes a Financial Consumer Alert List at bnm.gov.my. A name on an alert list is a reason to walk away; a name that appears on no licensed list at all is not much better.

Nobody running a legitimate investment needs you to borrow in order to join it.

When borrowing to invest is less unreasonable

There are cases where it is defensible. They share the same features, and you should be able to tick every one:

  • The effective borrowing rate, not the flat rate, is clearly below a conservative estimate of the return.
  • You already have an emergency fund and no credit card balance. If you have card debt at 15% to 18%, paying it off is a better return than anything on this page.
  • You could pay the instalment from salary alone for the whole term, and for at least six months with no salary.
  • Your time horizon for the investment is longer than the loan tenure, so you are never forced to sell to make a payment.
  • The amount is small enough that losing all of it would hurt and not ruin you.
  • You have checked the early settlement terms, so you know what it costs to stop. /blog/early-settlement-personal-loan-malaysia shows what settling early actually saves.

Where we stand

MyTrustCredit is a KPKT-licensed moneylender (Licence No. WL10287/2024) lending directly under the Moneylenders Act 1951. Personal loans run from RM 500 to RM 20,000 over 1 to 5 years, priced from 4% p.a. flat depending on your profile, with a processing charge and stamp duty set out in the Letter of Offer. As the sums above show, even the lowest flat rate has an effective cost above what capital-stable investments have recently paid.

We assess every application on your ability to repay from income, not on what an investment might earn, and we would rather you did not borrow from us to speculate. If you have spare monthly cash, /blog/year-end-bonus-debt-or-savings-malaysia sets out what to do with it first.

If you do have a real borrowing need, put the figure into /calculator and look at the total repaid as well as the instalment. That habit is the same one that would have answered the question in this article's title.

Continue reading

ShareWhatsApp

Related articles